When Supernatural ended, there was an explosion of meta about the show as a whole, from old and new fans alike. I also recently read
this article on Vox about pandemic grief and fandom-related mourning. I've wanted to collect my thoughts for awhile, but the
marchmetamatterschallenge pushed me to start. I do feel a certain kind of grief about SPN ending, but I think this is really the show's second death for me. The first death, the painful break-up, happened years ago.
My Experience with SPNI was a fan when the show first premiered, because it was on after Smallville and my VHS tape recorder was already running. Plus, I was a fan of Jensen Ackles from Smallville, so I wanted to watch. I've been looking at my old Livejournal posts, and I used to jot down my SPN-related thoughts after watching an episode each week or so. Apparently I was really into season 5? I stopped being so serious about this during Season 7, which is interesting because that was 2012 - the year I graduated from college. Maybe my fandom life in general changed at that point and I didn't realize until now. But 2012 was the year I started to really let SPN go.
I posted a couple of times about s11 in 2016, but I stopped watching altogether sometime during that year. The show changed dramatically, and the fandom along with it. I don't really know what's going on with SPN fandom these days but because of the finale, I'm re-dedicated to finishing it and I'm on s13.
The GoodI am definitely someone who liked the earlier seasons better, and I feel nostalgic about them. 2 of my sisters are much younger than me, and started watching the show way later - and they love Supernatural for different reasons (and they like the Angel storylines). So I have personal experience with the newer v. older viewers debate.
( More thoughts under here )